Choosing between Amazon and Walmart Marketplace is one of the most important strategic decisions a US ecommerce seller can make. Both platforms offer massive reach, trusted brand names, and powerful fulfillment networks – but they reward very different seller behaviors.
This guide goes deeper than a basic feature comparison. We analyze fees, competition dynamics, approval barriers, brand control, long-term growth potential, and risk exposure, so you can decide not just where to start – but where you’ll win.
Whether you’re launching your first product or diversifying beyond Amazon, this is a decision worth slowing down for.
Quick Take: Amazon vs Walmart at a Glance
| Factor | Amazon Marketplace | Walmart Marketplace |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly traffic | Extremely high | High, but more selective |
| Seller competition | Very intense | Moderate |
| Approval process | Open, automated | Selective, manual |
| Fulfillment | FBA (best-in-class) | WFS (improving rapidly) |
| Fees | Higher overall | Generally lower |
| Brand control | Moderate | Higher |
| Risk of suspension | High | Lower (but stricter entry) |
| Best for | Fast scaling, private label | Established brands, margin focus |
This table sets the stage – but the real decision lies in how each marketplace behaves under pressure.
Amazon Marketplace: Scale First, Ask Questions Later
Amazon is still the default choice for most US sellers – and for good reason.
Why Sellers Choose Amazon
1. Unmatched Buyer Intent
Amazon shoppers arrive ready to buy. In many categories, Amazon is the search engine for products. This translates to faster velocity, better data feedback, and easier validation of new SKUs.
2. FBA as a Growth Engine
Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) handles storage, shipping, customer service, and returns. For sellers, this means:
- Prime eligibility
- Higher conversion rates
- Operational leverage
For many businesses, FBA is what enables national scale without a warehouse.
3. Category Depth and Demand Testing
Amazon supports virtually every retail category. If you want to test demand quickly, no other platform provides better real-time data.
Where Amazon Gets Risky
Relentless Competition
Amazon rewards whoever wins today. Listings are constantly attacked by:
- Price undercutting
- Review manipulation
- Unauthorized sellers
- Listing hijacks
Margins shrink fast unless you actively defend your position.
Account Health Fragility
Amazon’s enforcement is algorithm-driven. Sellers can lose accounts due to:
- Policy misinterpretation
- Competitor complaints
- Automated IP claims
Appeals are possible – but revenue interruptions are common.
Rising Costs
Between FBA fees, storage surcharges, PPC costs, and returns, Amazon profitability often declines as revenue increases unless pricing power is strong.
Amazon Is Best If You:
- Need fast validation and scale
- Can compete aggressively on ads and optimization
- Have strong SOPs for account health
- Accept platform risk in exchange for volume
Walmart Marketplace: Slower Entry, Stronger Moats
Walmart Marketplace is often misunderstood. It’s not “Amazon Lite” – it’s a curated marketplace attached to America’s largest retailer.
Why Walmart Is Gaining Seller Attention
1. Selective Seller Approval = Less Noise
Walmart manually reviews sellers. This keeps:
- Counterfeits lower
- Listing quality higher
- Competition thinner
Once approved, sellers often enjoy more stable Buy Box ownership.
2. Lower Fees, Better Margins
There’s no monthly seller fee. Referral fees are often lower than Amazon’s, and WFS pricing is becoming more competitive – especially for oversized items.
3. Strong Omnichannel Advantage
Walmart’s physical store network enables:
- Faster last-mile delivery
- In-store pickup
- Local inventory advantages
This is difficult for Amazon to replicate fully grassy.
Where Walmart Still Lags
Lower Traffic Than Amazon
Walmart traffic is massive – but marketplace traffic is more controlled. Sales ramp slower, especially for new or unrecognized brands.
Stricter Product Standards
Walmart expects:
- Professional branding
- Clean compliance documentation
- Consistent pricing across channels
This weeds out many beginner sellers.
Fewer Seller Tools
Compared to Amazon, Walmart’s backend tools and advertising platform are less mature – though improving rapidly.
Walmart Is Best If You:
- Have an established brand or clean supply chain
- Care about long-term margin stability
- Want less daily firefighting
- Are expanding beyond Amazon dependence
Head-to-Head: Strategic Differences That Matter
1. Competition Style
- Amazon: Open battlefield; speed and spend win
- Walmart: Controlled ecosystem; reliability wins
2. Risk Profile
- Amazon: High upside, high volatility
- Walmart: Lower upside initially, lower existential risk
3. Brand Equity
- Amazon: Brand is secondary to listing performance
- Walmart: Brand credibility matters more than hacks
4. Advertising ROI
- Amazon Ads: Expensive but powerful
- Walmart Ads: Cheaper, less crowded, improving fast
Should You Sell on Both?
For many US sellers, the smartest answer is not “Amazon or Walmart” but “Amazon then Walmart”.
A common growth path:
- Validate product demand on Amazon
- Optimize branding, packaging, and compliance
- Expand to Walmart for margin protection and diversification
Multi-channel sellers consistently outperform single-platform sellers over the long term – especially during account suspensions or fee changes.
Final Verdict: Where Should You Sell?
There is no universal winner – only strategic alignment.
- Choose Amazon if speed, data, and scale matter most right now.
- Choose Walmart if brand stability, margins, and defensibility matter more.
- Choose both if you’re building a real, sellable ecommerce business.
If you’re serious about longevity, platform diversification isn’t optional – it’s insurance.
About This Guide
This article was written by ecommerce practitioners who actively research Amazon and Walmart marketplace policies, fee structures, and seller performance trends. Insights are based on real seller case studies, platform documentation, and ongoing marketplace changes affecting US sellers.
Frequently Asked Questions
